background

Why your schedule’s Total Slack might be wrong


November 17, 2026

In This Issue:

  • Resource Article: Enhancing Project Schedule Quality with Custom Graphical Indicators in Microsoft Project
  • From the Archive: In Defense of Hard Constraints
  • Video Tutorial: Microsoft Project Do’s & Don’ts - Constraining Activities
  • Live Event (11/18): An Introduction to the PMI Practice Standard for Scheduling Conformance Index

Tuesday Brief: Tomorrow Eric and Jeff Christoph show how PMI’s Practice Standard for Scheduling scores a schedule model. This week’s picks help you review your own file before the session. Ira Brown builds custom flags that call out common quality problems. Bridget Fleming, who helped write the standard’s second edition, makes her case for the one hard constraint she always uses. Sam Huffman shows how a constraint can lock a task in place no matter what happens around it.


Resource Article: Enhancing Project Schedule Quality with Custom Graphical Indicators in Microsoft Project

Ira Brown keeps a list of problems he looks for in any Microsoft Project schedule. It includes tasks that were never baselined, summary tasks carrying links or resource assignments, milestones with duration, and tasks with negative Total Slack. In this short article, he shows how to turn checks like these into custom fields with graphical indicators, so problem tasks show a red flag. He walks through the first check step by step. If you set it up this afternoon, you’ll have your own results in hand for tomorrow’s session.

​Read Article (4 minutes)​


From the Archive: In Defense of Hard Constraints

Most Microsoft Project advice says to mark a project due date with a deadline and steer clear of hard constraints. Bridget Fleming was a core team member on the second edition of PMI’s Practice Standard for Scheduling, and she disagrees. When a deadline falls later than your forecast finish, the critical path still shows zero Total Slack, so you can’t see how much cushion you really have. Her fix is one Must Finish On constraint on a separate milestone at the very end of the schedule, and she explains why it belongs nowhere else.

We’re resharing this 2015 article because Microsoft Project desktop still calculates slack this way, and Total Slack is part of what tomorrow’s session covers. Her definitions come from the standard’s second edition, which has since been updated. If you run the DCMA 14-Point Assessment, her Must Finish On will count toward the hard constraints check. That’s a good question to bring to Eric and Jeff tomorrow.

​Read Article (7 minutes)​


Video Tutorial: Microsoft Project Do’s & Don’ts - Constraining ActivitiesBridget places her one hard constraint on purpose. Sam Huffman shows what happens when constraints end up in a schedule without anyone planning them. He explains what the calendar icons in the Indicators column tell you, compares Start No Earlier Than with Must Start On, and then lengthens a predecessor while the Must Start On task refuses to move. By the end, you’ll see why he calls an absolute constraint a “schedule killer.”

​Watch Video (8 minutes)​


Live Event (11/18): An Introduction to the PMI Practice Standard for Scheduling Conformance Index

Tomorrow Eric and Jeff Christoph walk through PMI’s Conformance Index live. They’ll explain how the standard sorts schedule components into required, optional and not-scored groups and how the score is calculated, and they’ll leave time for your questions. The session is open to MPUG members.

What You’ll Learn:

  • How PMI’s Practice Standard frames a CPM schedule, from the method and tool to the model, its instances and the presentations your stakeholders see
  • How to use your contract and schedule management plan to tell which resource, risk and earned value components apply to your project
  • How the score is calculated, and why one missing required component keeps a schedule from being scored
  • A four-question method for assessing any component in Microsoft Project, ProjectXL or whatever tool you schedule in

🗓️ Wednesday, November 18
🕛 12:00pm - 1:00pm ET
📍 Live on Zoom
🏅 1 PMI PDU: Ways of Working

​Learn More + Register Here​

MPUG members get live access and replays. Not a member yet? Join today.


Upcoming Live Events

MPUG hosts live events with leading experts on Wednesdays from 12:00 - 1:00 PM ET. Members get live access and replays.

11/18: An Introduction to the PMI Practice Standard for Scheduling Conformance Index | Learn More + Register Here​

12/2: Upskilling Project Leadership: Building the Capabilities to Lead What’s Next | Learn More + Register Here​

12/9: Using Copilot in Excel - A Beginner’s Guide | Learn More + Register Here​

​View Our Upcoming Event Schedule​


PM Best Practice: Find the Constraints You Didn’t Mean to Set

Microsoft Project adds a Start No Earlier Than constraint when you drag a task bar or type a date into the Start field. Typing a date into the Finish field adds a Finish No Earlier Than constraint. Before you share a schedule, scan the Indicators column for calendar icons. If a constraint doesn’t reflect a real restriction, set the task back to As Soon As Possible.

Consider your constraints this week!

Share this newsletter on Socials

Follow MPUG for PM Tips + Training

​View our Privacy Policy​

1001 Woodward Ave Suite 500, Detroit, MI 48226
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

background

Subscribe to MPUG